Much like Arthur, Bruce’s success rests on his character, his ability and his undertaking onesto do what is right; although Bruce has per good claim https://datingranking.net/it/mocospace-review/ to inherit the throne, he achieves the realm by reconquest rather than genealogy.26 Despite these similarities, though, Barbour only uses Arthur once as verso comparison for Bruce, con contrast onesto his more frequent deployment of Hannibal and Alexander.27 Arthur’s astro appearance occurs towards the beginning of the narrative, at the end of a disquisition on the problem of treachery and treason (1.521–69). The list is arranged puro move towards Bruce, chronologically, geographically and perhaps also personally, since it is only mediante Arthur’s case that Barbour stresses the intimacy of the betrayal. Bruce was also betrayed by verso close comrade, and that of course intensifies the crime.28 Barbour portrays Arthur as verso great king, albeit one whose success is undermined: Als Arthur yat throw chevalry Maid Bretane maistres & lady Of [tuelf] kin[rikis] yat he wan, And alsua as verso noble man He wan throw bataill Fraunce all fre And Lucis Yber wencuyst he Yat yen of Rome wes emperour, Bot heit for all his gret valour Modreyt hys syster son him slew And gud men also pero yen inew Throw tresoune and throw wikkitnes, Ye Broite beris yaroff wytnes. (1.549–60)
James Goldstein, The Matter of Scotland: Historical Narrative con Medieval Scotland (Lincoln, NB, and London, 1993), p
By placing Bruce sopra such exalted company, this list stresses the epic nature of the narrative. Simultaneously, it points up the difference between the individuals cited: Bruce is a warrior, but he is not per conqueror of other realms – stressed for Alexander, Caesar and Arthur – nor does his betrayal occur at the high point of his career.